I come up
with the following concerns with Siemen’s theory:
·
Learners
may not be able to filter the information in terms of its accuracy and currency
·
Learners
may not be mature enough to know what is wrong
·
Topic/Subject
specific - how would learners learn
subjects such as LOTE
·
Monitoring
of learners’ motivation – who is going to “hook”?
·
Cyber
safety
·
Removal
of Teacher-Student engagement
·
Too
strong focus on cyberspace interaction – are we creating socially incompetent people?
·
Availabilities
of technology at school
However, I don’t totally disagree with Siemen’s
theory. I believe that the theory can be used effectively and efficiently in tertiary
education. I identify myself, as a GDLT student, using his theory in my
learning.
As we read in Presnky’s (2005) article, we,
as teachers, have to be flexible with the pedagogy we adopt in order to engage
learners. Perhaps a new “flexible” learning theory needs to be developed
because of the new technology. Theories such as behaviorism, social
constructivism, or cognitivism need to be updated to fill the current
requirements.
After
reading Siemen’s theory, I asked myself a very basic question – “What is
learning?”. Then as a pre-service teacher,
I decided to Google what the DETE says. I would like to share this with you;
Principals
and school staff support wellbeing by building a positive learning culture -
providing challenging, interactive and engaging learning experiences and by
nurturing relationships with families and the wider community. Students support
their own wellbeing by being actively involved in their school and community -
and research on resilience shows a sense of belonging is critical for young
people.
The Learning and Wellbeing Framework for
all Queensland state schools incorporates aspects of current practice and
supports schools to:
·
acknowledge the importance
of wellbeing to the learning process
·
develop a rich school
culture and positive ethos that creates a sense of belonging and
self-responsibility, leading to positive behaviour, improved student attendance
and achievement
·
embed personal and social
capabilities within the general curriculumI
·
improve educational
outcomes for all students.
(http://deta.qld.gov.au/initiatives/learningandwellbeing/)